Skip to main content
All Guides

Depression Care · Patient Guide

Treatment-Resistant Depression: Comparing TMS, SPRAVATO®, and Medication Care

When two or more antidepressants have not worked, how do you choose between TMS, SPRAVATO®, and psychiatric medication adjustments? A clear side-by-side comparison.

Modal Mental HealthPublished · Updated 6 min read

What treatment-resistant depression means in practice

Clinicians generally use the term treatment-resistant depression (TRD) when symptoms persist after trying two or more antidepressant medications at adequate doses and durations. It does not mean your depression cannot improve; it simply signals that another standard SSRI or SNRI may not be the best next step.

At Modal Mental Health, Dr. Taner Aydin and our team look at your full history, daily schedule, and personal preferences before recommending TMS, SPRAVATO®, or a refined medication plan.

Comparing your three main paths at Modal

Each option works differently and fits differently into your week:

  • TMS (In-Office): Uses targeted magnetic pulses in ~18–20 minute weekday visits (or 3-minute Express Theta Burst). No medication side effects, no sedation, and you drive yourself home immediately.
  • SPRAVATO® Esketamine (In-Office REMS Suite): Targets glutamate pathways via a supervised nasal spray with a mandatory 2-hour observation period. Requires a planned ride home and no driving until the next day.
  • Medication Management (Virtual NY or In-Office): Full 45–60 minute evaluations and 20–30 minute follow-ups available statewide via telehealth, ideal if you want a second opinion on psychopharmacology or want to combine medication with interventional care.

How an evaluation helps you decide without pressure

You do not have to figure out which treatment fits best before calling. Many patients start with a 45 to 60 minute evaluation via New York Virtual Care or in person at our West Islip clinic, review their insurance benefits upfront, and decide alongside a board-certified psychiatrist.

If you are in immediate crisis or having thoughts of self-harm, please remember that outpatient clinics cannot provide 24/7 emergency care. Call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, call 911, or go to the nearest emergency room.

Common Questions

During your evaluation, Dr. Aydin reviews your past medication trials, medical history, and schedule. Patients who need to drive themselves to work right after 20-minute visits often prefer TMS, while those seeking a glutamate-targeting nasal spray and able to plan a 2-hour visit with a ride home may consider SPRAVATO®.

More Patient Guides

All guides